The facts
FENAMAD and EarthRights International said the commission’s 23 October session ended without a final reserve decision and that nine of 16 members supported a proposal to update the state-approved 2016 additional categorization study. [2][3]
AP reported that the 2016 study recommended expanding the Madre de Dios Territorial Reserve, established for the Mashco Piro and other Indigenous peoples living in isolation. [1]
FENAMAD representatives warned that updating the study instead of proceeding with the proposal could delay territorial protection. The risk of logging exposure is the organization’s concern, not a report that the reserve was reduced or a concession granted. [1][2][3]
AP said Peru’s Ministry of Culture did not respond to its request for comment before publication. [1]
Still unconfirmed
- The official minutes, full proposal and ministry explanation for the 23 October vote were not located.
- The timing and outcome of any revised study or later reserve decision remain unknown.
- The exact effect of the vote on logging concessions and proposed reserve boundaries has not been established.
Sources
References support the numbered facts above. Source checks: 11 Nov 2026, 07:34 UTC.
AP and local reporting describe the commission action through FENAMAD and EarthRights; no official minutes or Ministry of Culture response were located. The vote is reported as a proposal to update the study, not a final reserve decision or withdrawal of existing protection.
- Peru’s move to reconsider protections for uncontacted Mashco Piro raises fears of Amazon logging
The Associated Press · Reporting · 9 Nov 2026
AP reports the decision through Indigenous organizations and quotes FENAMAD and a former government official; the Culture Ministry did not respond before publication.
- FENAMAD denounces delay over Madre de Dios reserve and warns of risk to Mashco Piro
Inforegión · Reporting · 28 Oct 2026
Local reporting interviews FENAMAD’s vice president and attributes the vote tally and concern to the Indigenous organization.
- Peruvian state decision threatens Mashco Piro territorial protection
EarthRights International · Reporting · 29 Oct 2026
EarthRights is an advocacy and legal organization working with FENAMAD; its “illegal” and “regressive” characterizations are not presented as neutral findings.