The facts
On Nov. 16, the Supreme Court denied certiorari in Katherine Novotny and others’ challenge to Maryland Governor Wes Moore, docket No. 25-1324. The official docket and order list record the denial without a majority explanation. [2][3]
Justice Clarence Thomas issued a separate statement respecting the denial. He said the petition combined distinct location restrictions and that a more narrowly focused case could be easier to review; this was Thomas’s statement, not a majority opinion. [2]
Thomas’s statement lists Maryland restrictions covering public demonstrations, mass transit, places of amusement, healthcare facilities, locations selling alcohol for on-site consumption, and extensive state park and forest land. He said the Fourth Circuit upheld all but one of the challenged locational restrictions. [2]
AP reports the denial leaves the challenged restrictions in place and does not decide their constitutionality. The Supreme Court’s order does not establish that the Court approved the lower court’s reasoning. [1][2]
Still unconfirmed
- Whether a future, more narrowly framed challenge will be filed or accepted for review.
- How any later Supreme Court decision will affect similar restrictions in other states.
Sources
References support the numbered facts above. Source checks: 16 Nov 2026, 22:26 UTC.
- Supreme Court declines to hear challenge to Maryland “sensitive places” gun law
The Associated Press · Reporting · 16 Nov 2026
Independent report of the denial, the state law and Thomas’s separate statement; it distinguishes the certiorari denial from a merits ruling.
- Order List (11/16/2026), Novotny v. Moore, No. 25-1324
Supreme Court of the United States · Primary source · 16 Nov 2026
Primary order and Thomas statement; the denial itself has no majority merits opinion.
- Docket for No. 25-1324, Novotny v. Moore
Supreme Court of the United States · Primary source · 16 Nov 2026
Official docket records the certiorari denial and links the detached statement.